In order to be descended from something
via any sort of process resembling evolution, at some point, you have to be
able to interbreed with the something.
Now, it was always a big mystery as to why there was never
any evidence of crossbreeding between modern humans and neanderthals despite
evidence of the two groups living in close proximity for long periods of time;
one fairly good description of the problem resides here:
http://discovermagazine.com/1995/sep/theneanderthalpe558
And then, in the late 90s, they
resolved the mystery by analyzing neanderthal DNA; the result they
turned up was that neanderthal
dna was about halfway between ours and that of a chimpanzee and pretty much
everybody involved in these studies views that as eliminating the neanderthal as a plausible
human ancestor, e.g.
http://biology.plosjournals.org/perlserv/?request=get-document&doi=10.1371/journal.pbio.0020080&ct=1
Until very recently some scholars have argued for the possibility that a tiny number of skull remains might constitute Neanderthal/human hybrids. A recent study however eliminates that possibility altogether.
The problem (for evolutionites) is, that all other hominids were further removed from us THAN
the neanderthal. In other words,
if you wanted to go on thinking that we are descended from hominids, you would
have to produce some new hominid closer to us both in time and morphology THAN
the neanderthal and the works and remains of such a creature would be all over the
map and exceedingly easy to find, had he ever existed. There is, of course,
zero evidence of it.
What that leaves as I see it is the reality that apes and
hominids are one family of creatures, and we are another. Possible choices for
an origin for modern man include:
1. Created here from scratch recently
2. Brought here from elsewhere in the cosmos
3. Genetically re-engineered from one of the hominids.
All three are plausible. There is overwhelming evidence that Mars
was once inhabited, giving you at least one possible extraneous origin, and
the genome of modern man shows unmistakable
evidence of genetic engineering.
The idea of modern man having evolved on this planet,
however, appears not to be defensible.